Isang Tanong: Presidential Forum
23 November 2009
42 Comments
Another great job by GMA News for having this Presidential Forum. Many many thanks also to TheBlockerOnline for uploading the videos para saming mga tiga-abroad and United States. Malaking tulong to para samen.
Isang Tanong: Presidential Forum
Noynoy Aquino:
Joseph Estrada:
JC De Los Reyes:
Bayani Fernando:
Teodoro Gilberto:
Eddie Villanueva:
Manny Villar:
Nicanor Perlas:
Final Question: from Efren Penaflorida
Paano ba maging bayani?
In this video: Manny Villar, Eddie Villanueva, Gilbert Teodoro, Nicanor Perlas,
In this video: Bayani Fernando, Joseph Estrada, JC De los Reyes, Noynoy Aquino
Fire your observations! What do you think? Who is the most Presidential?
Here’s my question:
Viewed 18826 times by 4067 viewers
Powered by WP Greet Box WordPress Plugin
Si Nicanor Perlas. Siya lang ang kandidatong merong totoo, practical at doable na platform.
Karamihan sa kanila generalized ang ideas (ako kaya ko ring sabihin ang sinasabi nila) o sa totoo lang wala talagang kapani-paniwala sa sinasabi nila.
Si Perlas, sa lahat ang sa tingin ko ang hindi trapo at maraming nagawa na hindi ibenandera sa buong sulok ng Pilipinas.
Agree ako dyan… kaso bakit parang wala sya dun sa poll choices?
Naku! Sorry! Check ko baka pwede pang ma-edit! Di ko napansin!
na-edit ko na. let’s wait 10 minutes daw to update. thank you for pointing that out.
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Silver, reyna_elena. reyna_elena said: RT @tweetmeme Isang Tanong: Presidential Forum | Barrio Siete http://bit.ly/5HcSxl [...]
I thought the Paano ba maging bayani question was good para ma-compare mo talaga bawat isa. So by process of elimination, kung sino ang winner sa question na to, tanggalin ko muna ang mga walang pag-asa saken:
Manny Villar:
Tanggalin ko si Manny Villar. I’m not impressed sa sagot nya na sya ang magiging bayani dahil he alluded na sya ang makakapag-lift nang mga problema naten pag nahalal sya. I thought the question should be answered deviating away sa pagkatakbo nya as Presidente. Hindi tuloy maganda ang sagot. I’m sure, na-throw off sya dun sa simpling question.
Joseph Estrada:
I will eliminate Joseph Estrada from my choices. I was not impressed at all by his response especially and I thought it was funny when he was asked on how to solve corruption. That was one weird question for him. Overall, he did not really perform very well.
JC De los Reyes:
I will also eliminate him from my choices. I am so not impressed by his response on Paano ba maging bayani question. Ako ang nahihirapang makinig.
Bayani:
The joke on Paano ba maging bayani question was good but it cost him time. Getting our acts together at gawin mong mabuti ang tungkulin mo will make you a bayani – nah. Hindi ako naantig.
Eddie Villanueva.
Tanggalin ko na rin si Eddie Villanueva. Wordy. Siguro nagulantang to. He’s used to memorizing things and now medyo nawala sya. I have no more idea what he’s talking – agree beholden ka dapat sa Pilipino lang pero that’s being nationalistic at hindi bayani.
I thought it was Noynoy, Gibo and Perlas who gave some good response.
Nick Perlas
Nick focused on prinsipyo at pananaw which is true. It’s a good reponse kaya lang kulang dahil being bayani is doing extraordinary work beyond what’s expected out of you.
Teodoro Gilberto
Gibo’s response is the correct bayani response. It’s using all god given talents and he mentioned the key word beyond the call of duty. Ang medyo na-off lang ako, and this is not by any means saying na hindi ko gusto ang military dahil mga pangkin ko andyan, but I am worried that Gibo always talk about military. Medyo nakakatakot ata ang eventuality na we’ve been under before ah! Is he trying to tell us “something”???
Noynoy Aquino
If Gibo brought the military in his answer, si Noynoy naman brought with him the church or Jesus Crist as his example which is a safe answer for me dahil Jesus Christ truly embodies… well… wag ko nang explain alam na naten yon. Noynoy focused on pakikitungo sa isang tao following the teachings of christ.
WINNER
For the BAYANI QUESTION, I’ll give this both to Gibo and Noynoy.
I think all of us are heroes in our own ways and that is what Perlas highlighted… TAYONG LAHAT… ALL OF US CAN BE HEROES AND ARE HEROES ON OUR OWN WAY.
Shen,
we all have the capacity to be heroes, unfortunately, some take the shortcut way para isahan ang mga pinoy
On the 3 Questions: JOSEPH ESTRADA
1st Question: Jessica Soho – Bakit gusto mong gusto mong tumakbo uli para magserbisyo or gusto mong bumawi?
Hindi raw sya nag-nakaw dahil the court was created to convict him. I feel sorry sa situation nya dahil he is running for President and he continues to be very defensive.
2nd Question: Amy Chua from DLSU – Ano ano ang pagkakamali nyo na hindi nyo na uulitin?
Ano daw ang pagkakamali nya dahil wala syang ginawang pagkakamali dahil ni isa sa Cabinet nya ay walang na-involve sa anomaly.
3rd Question: Select a Question – 4 – Kaya mo po bang sugpuin ang corruption.
“Madali yan.” Political will. I have no more comment.
Overall, I’m not really impressed. I’m sorry.
haha that’s true, he continues to deny or either or face the truth? matanda na pala si erap. it’s about time for him to make amends. i don’t even understand ba’t andyan sya. i think the questions to him were just fair.
Next was BAYANI FERNANDO:
1st Question: Jessica Soho: Given na dumaan tayo sa martial law, bakit daw tatakbo ang isang hitler, berdugo, kamay na bakal.
Response? Wala pa raw syang naipapakulong at naipapatay na tao. 18 years of service na daw sya. Hindi daw sya diktador. Wala raw daw syang kinalaman na gumawa sya nang karahasan. This must be in reference dun sa pag disperse nyang mga vendors.
2nd Question: Atty Victor Lazatin: Kalalabas nang survey nang Pulse Asia and with 1% rating and getting Lakas – will you continue to run habang mas kailangan kayo nang Marikina?
Desidido, pursigido at deretso. He has the political will. Pamantayan nang paglilingkod. He believes that Filipino people will understand him. Hmm… honestly, this was a good response kasi parang he’s saying it from his heart.
3rd Question: Number 8 : Ano pa ang iba mong motibo?
Kaligayahan nang lahat. Maiahon sa kahirapan. Mai-angat tayo. Mag-bago ang ugali. He’s got passion for building characters daw. Ewan di ako naimpress dito.
i don’t know about the dispersal much. di ko nabasa masyado yun. pero yun ang napi-feel ko ki Bayani, mukhang he seemed to be true to himself naman, although di ko kilala masyado sya and i don’t know much about all these hitler stuff.
pero iisa lang ang masasabi ko, leche ang mga uTurn na yan sa Manila especially kamo yong flyover dyan sa C5 galing sa Makati hahaha pag dun ang pinag-usapan di ako boto sa kanya at mas lalong di ko kursunada ang mga pink colors haha
well parang Espana at Manila, mga conquistadores na basagulero na ang alam sa Espana eh matitino ang mga impakto. yes, leadership ni bayani ang nakataya sa bawat palo na ginagawa nang mga tauhan nya. pero, i’m sure alam nya yon. denial is the best excuse. turo yan ni bill clinton heheh
Next was GILBERTO TEODORO:
1st Question: Kulelat survey. Mabigat ba na bagahe si Gloria Arroyo? Hindi raw. Kundi dahil sa kakulangan nang exposure nya.
Gibo is truly a good follower of Gloria. When he announced his candidacy and was asked if he will pursue Gloria’s wealth, wala raw yan sa agenda nya dahil there are justices to do that. Given na yong mga response ni Gibo to protect Gloria, expected na response yun. Kaya I’m not surprised na kahit si Gloria talaga ang reason nang lousy ratings nya, di nya maamin.
2nd Question: Mon Casiple. On insurgency that no president was not able to resolve. What is your final solution?
Hindi sustainable ang development sa ibang lugar dahil sa hindi napapansin ang peace and order dahil kulang ang investment sa kapulisan at sundalo.
Matindi ang question na to actually pero tama lang dahil he was the Sec of Defense. Curious lang ako, ano ang mangyayari sa mga kabayanan? militarized na naman sya? I remember sa bayan ko noon, andaming detachment, an daming pulis, an daming militar, at mas lalo kamong dumami ang NPA at mas lalong nagdusa kami, so I don’t know kung militarization ang solution sa insurgency. Or misunderstood ko lang sya?
3rd Question: Maganda yung tanong dahil eto yong mga hidden wealth or dito nangyayari yong mga gaya nang milyones ni Mikey Arroyo out of somewhere kaya lang why would you froze their assets? Kawawa naman ang mga pulitiko hahaha! Anyway, agree ako sa last part nang question na dapat ang sweldo mo is pantay lang sa economic performance naten and I agree with Gibo.
Overall: I’m impressed with Gibo’s eloquence. Hindi ako apprub sa ibang sinabi nya, hindi ko gusto yong Gloria response nya, but he’s good.
agree. ganun sa barrio namen. kaya medyo duda ako sa mga military response ni Gibo. nang hihinayang ako sa kanya. si gloria kasi haha
Ay salamat, kahit pasang awa binigyan mo ang kandidato ko.
Kidding aside, I cannot understand why the majority of people who responded to all these surveys are consistently giving Gibo a low mark. It’s obvious that the guy is a leader and an achiever. If it’s honesty and integrity that they like in Noynoy, then Gibo too has unblemished record when it comes to corruption. Personally, I don’t know him before he was candidate, but by just seeing and hearing him talk, and upon knowing his credentials, I am convinced right away that he is the ONE!!!
Thanks Reyns for being fair in your appraisal of him.
Teka lang, napansin nyo to?
I know hindi mananalo si Joseph Estrada, pero, can he still make it as far as the rigors of the campaign?
i think he should really get out of the race, magkakaron lang sya nang problema sa health nya if he continues to do this, besides hindi sya mananalo dito, nag-sasayang lang sya nang panahon.
To those in the United States na nag-email saken where JC De Los Reyes video, ayun, kakapost ko lang ho.
at hindi ko nagustuhan yong explanation nya about overpopulation dahil malaki pa raw ang lupain sa Pilipinas! HALLER! HAHAHA! Is it about land? Or jobs and food on the table? Ano ba?! Hahaha! I am so sorry at natatawa ako!
dapat nga blue, they should make a stand on overdevelopment dahil we need to protect the agricultural lands. tandaan ko yang dyan sa south superhighway which was dating mga sakahan, nangawala na sya, pati yong sa bayan namen in sorsogon, puro na subdivision. dapat kontrolado ang development dahil maliit ang pilipinas at mauubos ang arable lands.
On the 3 Questions: MANNY VILLAR
1st Question: As secret candidate ni Arroyo and anong stand nya sa controversies ni Arroyo.
Sya daw ang nagpursige and it was Nacionalista Party ang tumugis sa mga controversies ni Arroyo. Hindi daw nya kailagan ang tulong nang kaninuman. Aha! Eh si Pacquiao?
Hmmm…
2nd Question: Winnie Monsod: As House Speaker who impeached Estrada for using his position to enrich himself. At sya naman ngayon ang ina-aakusa to enrich himself. HAHAHA GRABE TONG SI WINNIE! Why should you seek the Presidency now dahil walang kaibahan ang kasalanan ni Estrada sa ginawa nya sa ginawa ni Villar. Hahaha! I want to be Winnie Monsod when I grow up! HAHAHA. Anyway, in essence, hindi daw tama ang accusation at nadismis na. Well, ang isang signatory dun was him. In essence, witness nya sarili nya and he vindicated himself. Hahaha! Sorry, natatawa ako.
3rd Question: Selected Question 10 – Ano anong mga hakbang para mawasak ang discrimination sa mga workers. Very broad. Puro give attention.
Sorry, pero I was not impressed.
I know napansin ko si Erap hahaha! Ayun! Nakaganti na si Erap, baka pwede na syang mag-back out haha
On 3 Questions: Nick Perlas
1st Question: Arnold Clavio: Agressive platform and pro-divorce and how do you win the church. I don’t see anything wrong with what he said, am not saying na pro-divorce ako. Realistic lang naman ang sinabi nya. Ang problema, ang simbahan. Mas lalong di sya mananalo.
2nd Question: Dahil environmentalist si Legarda, anong meron sya na wala si Loren?
Ano daw?! hahaha! Charing lang. Anyway. I think ang magiging problema nya is how to connect to people. Mukhang matalino. Now ko lang napakinggan sya. True. If you go green, dapat kasama mindset else, walang mangyayari.
3rd Question: Number 5 – Anong platform, national security, corruption and education.
Ano daw?!
Looked like he knows what he’s talking about. Mukhang matalino. Kaso malayong manalo to dahil he has to deal with the church and the other thing is how will he be able to connect sa mga common tao pagka ganito ang explanation nya?
Perlas is not a politician that is why he might have difficulties in trying to speak the common language hindi gaya ng mga seasoned politician na kumbaga alam na nila ang gusto ng tao. Perlas’ platform is anchored on 6 pillars which includes:
The first pillar aims to Eradicate Poverty and Enhance Quality of Life for all, through, among others, a vibrant broad-based economy, social justice and peace.
The second addresses the pervasive corruption that is tearing the social fabric of the nation and rupturing the hearts and minds of Filipinos. The second pillar therefore seeks to Advance Moral and Effective Governance in all institutions of society and all situations in life.
The third concerns itself with stopping the massive destruction of our ecology and our environment. The third pillar seeks to Uphold the Integrity of Creation and respectfully partner with it as our source of life.
The fourth pillar seeks to Build Partnerships for Social Justice. We want to introduce a new approach to real participatory governance and authentic democracy. No one can solve the problems of the country alone… tayong lahat ang kailangan upang mabago ang ating bansa. This means government working together with civil society and business in the pursuit of social justice and creating a better country.
The fifth pillar strives to Promote Creative Education and Inner Change. Better schools, colleges and universities, drawing out the many talents, intelligences, and potentials of students, are crucial. Equally as important is self-directed education and transformation. At the end of the day, it’s important to also address the factor of inner change—taking responsibility for changing our hearts and minds. No one can do our inner work for us. And there can be no genuine change in a system or institution if the people who work there do not change. Depressed, apathetic, and poorly trained people cannot create visionary and high-performance organizations, much less a world-inspiring country. Individual and cultural transformation are the foundations of the other pillars.
And then finally, the Sixth Psixillar of the platform aims to Mainstream Visionary Initiatives. There are thousands of promising initiatives throughout the country in a wide variety of fields that already point the way forward to another, much better Philippines.Innovation will be rewarded and will be systematicaaly discovered, magnified and multiplied so that these existing success stories will continue and spread.
now the question is, how do you sell this idea sa common tao?
On 3 Questions: Eddie Villanueva
1st Question: Vicky Morales: Kulelat sa 2004 pati sa Bulacan homeprovince. What’s the strategy to win now? Mina-ni-obra daw. Nakakatuwa si brother, mula sa zero naging point 1 daw agad hehehe, saken ayoko nang accomplishment na ganyan hahaha
2nd Question: Howie Severino: Separation of Church and State. Susundin mo ba? Democrat daw sya at di nya pag hahaluin yan.
3rd Question: Selected number 2: Lahat nang tumatakbo puro nasa isip ang mga mahihirap. Paano na ang mga middle class? Baon na sa utang at hirap. Ano ba yon, napaka-general masyado nang sagot!
My general opinion. Ewan.
FINALLY: NOYNOY AQUINO
The bad news:
1st – I don’t like his posture. He needs to sit properly. Like a President. Asan ba si Kris at di tinuruan ang koya nya. You guys should look at how Gibo sat, ganun.
2nd – What happened to him?! How come para syang turbo charger sa bilis nang sagot?! I think he should slow down and focus on clarity. Mukhang kabado baka dahil sa time.
The good news:
1st Question: Wala daw syang accomplishment and that si Cory and Ninoy lang ang qualification nya.
Response? He enumerated the list of laws na hindi nya pinasa sa Senado or hindi pinalusot and to deliver the final punch, I thought this was brilliant na sabihin yang, ang definition nang accomplishment sa Senado ay hindi lamang base sa laws na nai-pasa kundi sa mga laws na pinaglaban mong wag ipasa dahil mapapasama ang karamihan. Para saken, that was an excellent point.
2nd Question: Ano ang tatlong bagay na aasikasuhin once you become President.
Ang ikalawang tanong ay nagmula sa PCIJ na kung ano yong tatlong areas na kanyang tututukan nang pansin sakaling manalo sa pagiging President. Instead na tatlo, nagbigay sya nang apat:
1. Jobs,
2. Education
3. Health
4. Judicial Reform
3rd Question: Ang ikatlong tanong sa kanya na napili nya ay ganito: kung sya daw ba ay masasangko sa corruption habang nasa pwesto, sya ba ay magbibitiw sa pwesto.
Ang sagot nya ay “mahirap naman pag nasangkot lang. kailangan naman mapatunayan. may karapatan lahat kahit presidente na ipagtangol ang sarili nya ayon sa batas at hustisya. at tumanda na ako ng ganito na di ako nasasangkot sa katiwaliaan, sasayangin ko ba naman at sisirain ang pangalan ko gayong malapit na akong magretiro sa politika”
True. Equal opportunity. And I believe yan ang magnet ni Noynoy Aquino sa mga tao dahil hindi sya corruptible.
I’d say, I’m impressed with his response. I think he did great and provided excellent answers. Like Gibo, he is eloquent and he knows his stuff very well, although he needs improvement in his delivery gaya nung mga naririnig ko sa 60 seconds video nya where klaro ang delivery.
hay! finally tapos na ako! ayan! that’s how i rated the candidates. bahala kayo mag-husga. play the video and listen to them. kahit Noynoy ako, i tried my best to be fair.
I think parehas tayo Blue. Those were the three who made good impressions to me.
I like Perlas dahil he knows what he’s talking about and although i don’t know the guy, sabi ko nga matalino at yan din ang napansin ko, he has to learn how to speak to common tao, else, pano nya maide-deliver ang mensahe nya kahit ganu kaganda?
I like Gibo. He acts Presidential, he is intelligent and he is very eloquent besides, prejudiced talaga ako sa mga magagandang credentials, i think ganun lang talaga ako. Kaso, denial sya na si Gloria ang nag-pu-pull sa kanya and I am also worried about his military responses.
I like Noynoy and I like the fact na he gave such excellent response given na he was being pulled down as autistic. Ngayon ko lang napakinggan nang todo si Noynoy like this and I truly believe na matalino si Noynoy on his own. One thing I noticed, sya lang ata ang magalang sa lahat and you could feel the Cory son in Noynoy sa pagiging magalang.
Simple lang naman ang tanong na how to be a bayani (hero) and main gist lang naman dun is to do something out of the extra-ordinary for the many of course along the line of goodness and greatness at yun ang sinagot nung tatlo, si Perlas, si Gibo and si Noynoy and yes, mukhang well-applauded and sagot ni Noynoy.
Reyz, kung ang military tendencies ni Gibo ang ayaw mo, ako naman yan pa ang isa sa nagustuhan ko sa kanya. It’s about time that we have a just but strong leader. Puro na lang pagbibigay ginagawa ng goberno sa mga kalaban ng bansa gaya ng NPA at Abu Sayyaf. Ano pa ba ang pinaglalaban ng mga ito eh di ba may freedom na tayo. Bakit pa sila patuloy na gumagamit ng armas eh demokrasya na nga. Minsan nagiging unfair na tuloy tayo sa mga sundalo natin. Pag NPA at Abu ang namatay, sigaw natin human rights. Pag sundalo naman naambus, tahimik tayo.
Ay ano ba, nalihis ako. Sorry Reynz, now back to Gibo.
Hindi pa ako makareact..litsi! tinatapos ko pa ang mga video! Hahhaha.
Nicanor Perlas has done well in his 40 years of public service and if he had done the impossible even outside of politics then he will also do good when he comes in… Tayong Lahat ang Solusyon… yun ang totoo… hindi lang ang gobyerno at ang pangulo.
Mas tumibay lang lalo ang suporta ko for Noy but he has to maintain his lead. marami pa siyang dapat gawin.
Gibo isn’t a bad choice too. yun nga lang his affiliation with Gloria is a big minus for me. promising yet disappointing.
Nick Perlas is way better than the other presidentiables. if only he is popular or has enough machinery to support his candidacy.
The rest of them wala akong comment. they bore me. LOL
Mel, kung ang affiliation ni Gibo with GMA ang basehan mo, di ba dapat ganun ka rin kay Noynoy dahil affiliated siya kay Erap? Naging senador lang iyan dahil pinakiusap ni Tita Cory kay Erap na isama siya sa lineup noong 2007. Association with a perceived plunderer (GMA) is bad. Association with a convicted plunderer (Erap) should be worse if we are fair in our assessment.
No, because I’m talking about the present. Noy and Erap is from different parties and they have different stand and opinion on certain issues. While Gibo is being endorsed by Gloria and he plans to carry out her unfinished business. I don’t like what Gloria is doing to our country right now so why let someone continue and finish it for her.
kung totoo man yong affiliation ni Noynoy ki Erap, it won’t stick and it doesn’t stick dahil poles apart ang Aquino and Estrada. Brand Aquino is about clean politics and incorruptibility and proven na yan from Ninoy and Cory and because of the image, people are magnetized by it kaya Noynoy continues to be very popular. Erap will be Erap and his baggage will just be his.
unfortunately ki Gibo, one good guy, intelligent and eloquent and there is no reason that he could not be a good leader, kaya lang he’s no listening to what the masses dislike, si Gloria, and that association stuck kaya problemang bagahe si Gloria ki Gibo and it’s so not fair for a guy like Gibo. Pinili ni Gibo to be with Gloria so risk yan na tinanggap nya. and the ratings says it all. kung talagang gusto ni Gibo maging Presidente, he should have not associated with her.
[...] you seen GMA-7’s Presidential Forum? Well, kung hindi pa ay pumunta kayo DITO at [...]
For me, I can feel that Noynoy Aquino gave the sincerest answers of them all. He is very firm on the issues of the government budget and very aware of the economic scenario of our government.
Based on the answer responses I thought the following did a good job, in this order:
1) Fernando
2) Perlas
3) Villanueva
4) Aquino
5) Teodoro
Gibo Teodoro has consistently impressed me in numerous public forums. Sayang talaga, he is in his elements and really knows what he is doing. Off-putting nga lang yung buntot-paliwanag nya sa ‘bayani’ question.
Perlas too is very very impressive. He knows what he is talking about but maybe because of the time element masyadong vague and generalized and mga sagot nya. Plus he moves his hands a lot and his facial expressions do not really vary.
Noynoy, for this forum, for me, finishes third. Generic responses, nothing new, but then again, promising and sincere.
These are my choices based on the show, and not necessarily reflective of my voting choice.